There is an unfortunate story that I have been following for several months; I’ve tried to ignore it, but it simply won’t go away. Anita Tedaldi, a former adoptive parent, has been making her rounds in the media, first in the New York Times, and then on the Today show; she has now crossed the Atlantic to appear in The Guardian to continue garnering attention for her vile self and her story. Since it seems as though people are tripping all over themselves to congratulate this narcissistic subhuman mess of a woman on her “selflessness” and “heroism” for giving up her adopted child, I figured I’d add my voice to the chorus of those (including the more articulate folks over at Racialicious, Resist Racism, and ChinaAdoptionTalk- all of whom have written critically and extensively about this case, and done a lot more research into Tedaldi’s background than the venerable Guardian or NY Times) who think Tedaldi needs to shut the hell up.
To make a long story short, Tedaldi brought home her toddler son Matteo from Ethiopia (although she has lied about this and claimed he’s South American), decided she and Matteo were not attaching to one another, and gave him away. She then proceeded to write about it on the Times’ Motherlode blog, lie about other surrounding circumstances, and garner attention and airtime for herself at the expense of this poor child. Oh, and what were those circumstances? Just some minor facts, like the fact that she was pregnant during the adoption and had two biological children in the two years following it, or that her soldier husband was deployed for months on end leaving Tedaldi to parent five or six kids alone, or that she parented her son for a long year and a half (which she has also lied about, claiming it was only a few months) before finding him a new home. Despite going through what Tedaldi describes as a thorough screening process for the adoption, it seems she and her family offered little potential for meeting the needs of fragile baby Matteo.
As I watched the clip of Tedaldi being interviewed by Matt Lauer on the Today show, portraying herself as a loving mother who did what was best for her child, I almost threw up in disgust. It was just all about her: her feelings, her grief, her magnanimous spirit in setting Matteo free. *NOT ONCE* does Tedaldi seem to accept responsibility for the outcome of their adoption. *NOT ONCE* does she point to any of the critical factors- her absent husband, multiple pregnancies in quick succession, her lack of preparation for attachment issues- that set Matteo up for failure in her family. She doesn’t seem interested in preventing other adults from putting children through what Matteo experienced. No, she did this so that others who do so don’t have to feel quite as guilty as she claims she did.
I will never pretend that parenting through adoption is the same as giving birth to a child who is biologically yours. It is not. Adoption is hard fucking work in ways that parenting Bo never was. Bo IS me and Adam. He looks like us, smells like us, talks like us, thinks like us. Sula and Dawit were so…foreign when we met them, as I’m sure we were to them. I wouldn’t hesitate to share a water bottle with Bo, but for a long time it felt strange to do the same with Sula, as though even her germs were completely different from ours. The differences were even more profound with Dawit. Have you ever cut the toenails of a nine-year-old child that didn’t belong to you? Yeah. It’s unpleasant on a profoundly visceral level…and yet I’m sure I wouldn’t have even thought twice about doing it for Bo.
But you know what? WE SIGNED UP FOR THIS. Sula and Dawit didn’t. So in those first few months home, when we were changing foul diapers and collecting stool samples and accepting enthusiastic wet kisses from clingy children who only weeks before had been virtual strangers to us, we sucked it up, because we were the adults. Hell, over a year later it’s STILL hard and we STILL have to suck it up. If you read my blog, and especially if you know me in real life, you know that I don’t think attachment comes easily. There were many days where we felt that we had made a big fat mistake by adopting. I’d be lying if I said that thought doesn’t occasionally cross my mind on a particularly tough day even now. One of the worst aspects of experiencing attachment difficulties after adoption is the knowledge that we were the ones who chose this life, the ones who asked to bring these children into our family. But the solution wasn’t to add more biological babies to our brood, find a new family for our adopted kids, and sell our story in the media. No, we work on attachment and will continue to do so for the rest of our lives. That’s what we committed to when we decided to adopt our children.
It’s obvious that nothing anyone says will cause Anita Tedaldi to look deeper into herself and realize that she is a failure as a parent and a human being. But I can at least hope that the media will stop giving this woman a platform from which to bray her narcissistic virtues.























































